Just out of interest why are you still ignoring the 4 top 10 finishes considering you’ve said he’s a bottom half league one manager at best?
Dean Smith finishes at Walsall:
13/14: 13th (much worse than I thought)
15/16: 2nd (up to end of November)
Surely you’d make the same point about Dean then? Even though he’s been given a chance and shown he’s a reasonable manager at championship level?
TBH I normally don’t get involved in these never ending debates and also had to log off for my own sanity as I think two 20 somethings arguing on a message board at close to midnight about Keith Hill isn’t a great stage in life…
Call me bonkers but if the worst happens then Keith Hill would be right at the top of my list to start a comeback from league two just as Money did. His record been pretty mediocre in management since leaving Walsall btw…