Charlton Athletic (H) F A Cup 2nd round, Nov 30th 3pm

"Down Greenwich reach
Past the Isle of Dogs"

(Eliot)

Away from the trials and tribulations of League 2, we have a game offering us a potential passport to untold riches when the “big” clubs enter the draw in the F A Cup 3rd round. First we have to get past the Addicks, and if you thought that Walsall’s ownership comings and goings were newsworthy just compare that with the recent goings-on at Charlton - like 4 new owners in less than four years…

Charlton currently sit exactly half-way up (or down) League 1, in 12th place having played 16 matches, winning 6 and losing 6 with a goal difference of Zero (17-17). Manager Nathan Jones was appointed in February this year and doesn’t seem to be flavour of the month according to a prominent forum. Their current League 1 form looks like this:-

October 19th Stockport County (H) Drew 1-1
October 22nd Barnsley (A) Drew 2-2
October 26th Wrexham (H) Drew 2-2
November 9th Exeter City (A) Lost 1-0
November 23rd Huddersfield Town (A) Lost 2-1
November 26th Burton Albion (A) Won 0-1

Incidentally, for those who were griping about our 4,424 attendance at home to Bromley, the gate at Burton Albion on Tuesday was reported as 1,749 - Christmas is round the corner I guess!

I haven’t researched the undoubted hundreds of players who have represented both clubs, as I have a particular mental block where Charlton Athletic is concerned. I was one of many thousands who witnessed “that game” at the end of the 1962/63 season when all we needed was to draw at home to Charlton to preserve our Division II (Championship) status. To cut a very long story short the game was scheduled for a Tuesday night and abandoned at half-time after the heavens had opened and flooded the playing area. Re-arranged for the Friday night before Cup Final Saturday we were holding our own when our goalkeeper (Alan Boswell) was stretchered off having sustained a fractured jaw. No substitutes in those days, so an outfield player had to suffice. We also had another player as a complete passenger (hobbling on the wing), and we let a couple of goals in. True to Walsall form we actually managed something of a come-back and scored to make it 1-2. After that we seemed to pepper their goal, testing the strength of the woodwork in several places, all to no avail. Charlton won, and those two points brought them up equal to us, but we were relegated on a slightly inferior goal average (0.596 vs 0.660). Heigh Ho…

Incidentally (and here’s a “trivial pursuit” question), did you know that in the famous comedy series “Only Fools and Horses” Rodney’s full name is Rodney Charlton Trotter?

Prediction? Mat Sadler will probably ring the changes following a somewhat tired showing against Bromley. It is also important to bear in mind that we have a few vital League 2 games on the near horizon, and promotion must remain the priority. Nevertheless I would think we have enough strength in the squad to register a home win (say 2-0) and then wait for the inevitable banana skin of someone like Brackley Town in the next round!

UTS

18 Likes

Excellent welsh :+1:

1 Like

Beat these , get an out of form Premiership team like Man City , win, get famous , Lowe wants to stay , ryan Reynolds wants to come to Walsall instead and sells Wrexham , we have our own documentary and Merson even mentions us on sky sports

2 Likes

If you ask me, he’s been gone too long.

7 Likes

I’d like to see:

Simkin

McEntee Williams Allen

Barrett Jellis Comley Lakin Gordon

DJ Lowe

Think Stirk needs a rest… as does Matt.

I’m more bothered about the County game - and I think that’s our best back 3 personally.

12 Likes

Makes more sense to rest Matt against Notts

Either or as long as we give someone else a go.

I’d agree with all that. People say how crucial Matt is to the way we play, and that is fair enough, but we also need to have another way of playing / adapting better if he suddenly gets injured and ends up on the sidelines for a while. Be good to see the likes of Cleary on the bench again and make decent changes at decent times in the game to give some starters a rest ahead of the big L2 games.

2 Likes

I wouldn’t be against Weir having a run out instead of Allen. Allen was very poor yesterday, probably also needs a rest, he plays 90 mins most games. Agree with your best back 3 but big Dave has improved.

Nothing against DJ having a start, is Cleary a write off now? I really thought he would have played more minutes by now, not struggling to get on the bench.

I agree Notts is more important but I think we have a good chance of winning as long as we don’t go too weak.

A free hit this . I would bring Weir in at LCB. And start with DJ and Cleary up front. Those two both need games because they will be needed in the weeks ahead. Adomah for Barrett on the right too as he looked tired on Tuesday.

1 Like

Yeah I thought those ones too… same as @Blazing_Saddler mentioned above but fear that might be too many changes ?

I think both Gordon and Barrett need a rest!

Be very interesting to see which way we go on Saturday!

1 Like

Errrrr… surely you know the way to the ground by now :thinking::crazy_face::rofl:

2 Likes

May be in the minority here, but i think we missed Lakin on Tuesday. Im not sure if Barrett was tired, i just thought he was very complacent. I for one will be happy to exit the Vertu trophy against Reading.

5 Likes

To be fair, with 3 kids, highly likely we turn round and go back home :joy:

1 Like

Fair point, well made :rofl::rofl:

1 Like

I think taking both Jellis and Lakin out at the same time was an error.

Lakin is definitely a little underrated. I think fans were expecting a midfielder that scored quite a few goals and would be very attacking but he actually does a lot of leg work and some of the nitty gritty.

Barrett has gone off the boil a little, not that he has been awful or anything, he just isn’t beating his man with the ease he was. Probably has been picked up by other teams he is one of our main threats.

2 Likes

@Welsh_Saddler Excellent preview. Here’s the somewhat futile pitch inspection after that half time deluge v. Charlton in 1963!

8 Likes

25 Likes

One thing is for certain, given our record against L1 sides, they won’t take us lightly.

1 Like

I fancy the same result as bolton. They’ll attack us. We’ll pick em off on the counter attack. 2-1 to the saddlers