So, I have seen a few people suggesting Walsall fans are using Port Vale’s success as ‘a stick to beat the club with’ (how many times have we read this). So, I thought I would take the time to do some digging and look at the facts.
Kevin & Carol Shanahan bought out Norman Smurthwaite, a chairman considered very much in the same vein as our own Mr Bonser by Vale fans, in 2019 for a value way over the clubs worth, in turn uniting the club with its own stadium. In January 2020 Karen took over total control of the club.
CEO Colin Garlick has been named League Two CEO of the Year in the Football Business Awards and shortlisted for the overall CEO of the Year Award by fcbusiness - he played an integral role in ousting Smurthwaite and bringing in the Shanahan’s, Karen said if it wasn’t for Garlick she would not have be able to complete the takeover at the club. He was the only reappointment to the board, all other CEO’s were replaced on 11 February 2020 after Karen took total control, mostly by CEO’s from the Shanahans other business, Synectics.
Shanahan then appointed DOF David Flitcroft, poached Darrel Clarke, paying compensation to us in Jan / Feb 2021, after sacking John Askey with Vale in a below expected 17th place.
So in summary, Shanahan took control in May 2019, cleared out the boardroom by Feb 2020, united the club with the stadium at purchase point, set up a DoF role and new football structure following the sacking of an underperforming manager, and poached a manager from a rival who then was fully backed and won promotion the following year.
Leigh Pomlett took control of Walsall in July 2019….he had been on the board since 2010.
A pretty damning indictment I would say, but of course everyone is free to draw their own conclusions - but please don’t try to tell me anybody is unduly criticising LP.
Oh, and if you want to compare the Vale board room to our own 90s boys club, take a good look at this article and the image: Getting to know Port Vale’s Chief Operating Officer, Claire Halket | News | Port Vale